BUS FPX 4045 Assessment 4 Developing an Interview Plan

Student Name

Capella University

BUS-FPX4045 Recruiting, Retention, and Development

Prof. Name:

Date

Structured vs. Unstructured Interviewing

In the context of interview processes, the level of structure and planning significantly influences the effectiveness of candidate evaluations. A structured interview process is often chosen to ensure fairness and consistency. This section compares structured and unstructured interviews and explains the rationale for selecting the structured approach.

A structured interview is a formal format that includes predetermined questions and a rating scale, which ensures an objective comparison of candidates. This approach is focused on evaluating specific skills and gathering feedback on how well candidates align with the company’s needs. The structured process helps maintain consistency across all interviews, ensuring that each candidate is evaluated under the same conditions. This format minimizes biases and increases the chances of selecting the most qualified candidate. By adhering to a structured approach, interviewers can focus on obtaining the relevant information and making well-informed decisions.

BUS FPX 4045 Assessment 4 Developing an Interview Plan

In contrast, unstructured interviews are more informal and resemble casual conversations. These interviews may lack a set of predefined questions, relying on information from the candidate’s resume and application instead. While they offer flexibility, the absence of structure can lead to chaotic interactions and subjective evaluations, which may result in biases or misinterpretations. Furthermore, unstructured interviews carry legal risks as they can unintentionally expose candidates to questions that violate regulations, such as those concerning personal information. Therefore, sticking to a set of prepared questions is crucial to avoid potential legal challenges and ensure fairness throughout the process. Council (2019) highlights the advantages of structured interviews, emphasizing the need for consistency, fairness, and informed decision-making.

Interview Question Styles

Effective interviewing involves using a variety of question types to gain a comprehensive understanding of a candidate’s skills and qualifications. These include behavioral, situational, and competency-based questions. Behavioral questions ask candidates to describe past experiences that demonstrate their problem-solving abilities and skills. Situational questions, which are similar to behavioral ones, present hypothetical scenarios to assess the candidate’s decision-making and analytical abilities. Competency-based questions focus on evaluating the candidate’s knowledge and abilities relevant to the job.

By incorporating these different question styles, interviewers can gain a well-rounded view of the candidate, examining both their qualifications and their ability to perform in various situations. It is important to maintain consistency in questioning to ensure fairness and allow for objective comparison of all candidates. Standardizing the interview process helps create a level playing field, thus enhancing the reliability of the hiring decisions.

Avoiding Illegal Questions During the Interview Process

Certain questions are deemed illegal in job interviews because they can lead to discrimination and violate candidates’ rights. Questions related to a candidate’s race, religion, marital status, gender, disability, or health are prohibited by law. To avoid these legal pitfalls, it is essential for interviewers to follow a structured interview process with predefined questions. This approach not only helps maintain focus on the relevant job-related topics but also prevents the inadvertent inclusion of inappropriate or illegal questions.

Failure to comply with legal interview practices can result in severe consequences, including discrimination lawsuits, regulatory investigations, and damage to the company’s reputation. By adhering to structured interview protocols and focusing on job-relevant topics, organizations can mitigate legal risks and make well-informed hiring decisions. Beasley (2022) provides insights into common illegal interview questions and strategies to avoid them, underscoring the importance of legal compliance in the hiring process.

Table: Structured vs. Unstructured Interviewing Comparison

Criteria	Structured Interviewing	Unstructured Interviewing
Format	Formal, predetermined questions, rating scale for consistency.	Informal, conversational, no set questions.
Evaluation Process	Objective comparison of candidates based on responses.	Subjective evaluation, prone to biases and inconsistencies.
Fairness	Ensures fairness by following the same process for each candidate.	May be influenced by personal bias or misinterpretation.
Legal Compliance	Reduces risk of legal violations due to structured questions.	Higher legal risks from unintended sensitive questions.
Decision-Making	Informed, based on specific skill evaluations.	Chaotic and potentially inconsistent decision-making.

References

Beasley, C. (2022, December 27). Common illegal interview questions & how to avoid them. Fit Small Business. https://fitsmallbusiness.com/illegal-interview-questions/

Council, Y. E. (2019, July 19). Council post: Structured versus unstructured interviews. Forbes. https://www.forbes.com/sites/theyec/2019/07/19/structured-versus-unstructured-interviews/?sh=1d9964e64780

Simpson, M. (2022, June 6). Top 50 situational interview questions and answers (examples included). The Interview Guys – Job Interview Prep, Interview Questions & Career Advice. https://theinterviewguys.com/situational-interview-questions-and-answers-examples-included/